Saturday, October 17, 2009

Athens Township PA: Water = Mother = Earth: also The Value of Censorship and Banishment in Democracies

Thanks for posting this, Cris. (see below)

I am reminded that one year ago,
the "official spokesperson" of the Binghamton Regional Sustainability Coalition
Adam Flint, was quoted in the Press+Sun saying about the BRSC:

"We are not necessarily opposed to the [Marcellus Shale] gas drilling."

When I asked, "WTF!?" on the BRSC listserv,
and questioned the motives and mission of the organization,
I was banned. Apparently permanently.
(at least until now... hopefully reason will prevail)

It seems to me that in a Democracy,
everyone is supposed to be allowed
to vote, speak, and participate.

Hey all of you people in the BRSC:
Tarik Abdelazim, Ken Holmes, Amelia LoDocle, Adam Flint,
Chris Burger, Erin Riddle, Lynn Sennick --

Athens PA is where my mom was from.
Water = birth = life = mother = earth.
No water? No life, no birth, no Mother Earth.

You are talking about my mom.

  • Q: Does the BRSC still endorse
    or "not oppose" this (unsustainable) drilling?

  • Q: Is the BRSC still unable or unwilling to find a spokesperson
    who can engage the press with much more powerful polemics
    which vigorously assert the rights of nature and life?

  • Does the BRSC (like our State University, like the Binghamton IMC)
    ...still practice controlled speech, censorship, banishment
    as tools to silence critics who pose embarrassing questions?

I want to pose an essay assignment to you all,
any of you, especially you Democrats
especially my friends Tarik and Adam
who have advocated for my censorship/banishment
on more than one occasion:

1: What role does censorship or banishment play in a democracy?

2: In a democracy, are there some people so offensive,
with judgment so impaired, that they deserve to be stripped
of their rights of voting, free speech, and public participation,
as punishment for their sins,
and as protection for what they might do or say?

3: If certain rules must be enforced, then who gets to make the rules?

4: In a democracy, are rights inherent?
Or provisional, granted by some authority?

Take as much time as you like. I'd suggest 1,000 words,
but that's your call :)

Because if the words "democracy" "sustainability" "grass roots" and "consensus"
comes out of your mouths one minute
and you act again and again to censor and banish,
guess what that makes you?

My point here is not to call you
Machiavellians, disingenuous liars, hypocrites, and frauds.

My intention here is Satyagraha:
speaking truth to encourage you
to act consistently with your stated values

(because your stated values are often good ones)

Kind Regards,

On Sat, Oct 17, 2009 at 2:56 PM, Cris McConkey <> wrote:

-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Fw: Athens Township: Questions arise over wastewater treatment plant
Date: Sat, 17 Oct 2009 14:39:54 -0400
From: Ruth S. Young <>
To: <"Undisclosed-Recipient:;">

Alert to Concerned Citizens in Schuyler County....are you going to get asked to do this also?
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Saturday, October 17, 2009 2:23 PM
Subject: Athens Township: Questions arise over wastewater treatment plant

Look what's happening:
  • 18 miles south of Van Etten
  • 24 miles south of Erin
  • 26 southeast of Horseheads

Local News


By Steve Reilly
Staff Writer
Saturday, October 17, 2009 1:17 AM EDT
ATHENS TOWNSHIP— One of the most challenging pieces of the area's gas drilling puzzle is the question of what will be done with "flowback water" — the millions of gallons of contaminated water that will travel back to the surface of each well after it is hydraulically fractured.

One possible solution is the wastewater treatment plant that a Tunkhannock-based Somerset Regional Water Resources LLC (SRWR) is hoping to construct in Athens Township.

The plant is being proposed for development at a site in the Valley Industrial Park on Mile Lane Road, which is zoned "industrial" under the Athens Township code. But because the plant does not fit the criteria for the "industrial" zoning, SRWR's plans are currently going through a conditional use permitting process.

A copy of the conditional use permit application obtained by the Morning Times provides details about how the plant will be used.

"The anticipated volume of water that will be offloaded to the facility on a daily basis will be 1.5 million gallons," it states.

The document indicates that trucks carrying the flowback water will arrive at an offloading station where the water will be pumped into a series of "skim ponds." In these ponds, oil and grease will be taken off of the surface of the water and shipped away from the site for disposal.

After the skimming process, water will be stored in "lined earthen impoundments" in accordance with DEP requirements. The aeration provided by the open-air storage will help remove minerals including iron and sulfides from the water.

Then the water will go through a process designed to remove and condense the chemicals in the water to a solid "sludge" that will be shipped off-site to an approved landfill. This will involve the use of caustic soda and hydrated lime to settle the solids in the water, as well as the use of a "hydrocyclone" — a cone-shaped centrifuge used for separating mixed liquids.

The permit application states "Radium 226, Radium 228, Gross Alpha, and Gross Beta radiation" are present in the water incoming for treatment, and because of this, "SRWR is concerned that concentrations (of radioactive materials) will accumulate in the clarifier sludge, rendering the sludge a radioactive waste."

The document adds that SRWR is considering two different methods to help reduce the radioactivity of the sludge, and that "evaluation is continuing to determine the optimum location for this process and the most appropriate and safest means for handling and disposing of the waste that would be generated."

Finally, the document details how the water would be dealt with after the sludge is separated and removed. At this point, it would still have an extremely high concentration of salt and other concentrated organic materials.

Through a "reverse osmosis" process — the same that is used to remove the salt from seawater in some Middle Eastern countries — salt would be removed from the water until it fell below limits set by the EPA's National Pollution Discharge Elimination System program.

The salt would then go through a process that would make it available for commercial reuse. The processed water would be put in holding ponds from which it will be picked up by trucks for reuse as fracing fluid at natural gas wells.

Any excess water not trucked away for reuse at natural gas wells is to be discharged through a pump station into the Chemung River. The document states that an effluent monitoring station will be in place at the discharge site to ensure regulatory compliance.

It takes approximately 3.5 million gallons of water to hydraulically fracture an average well in the Marcellus Shale. According to Bryan Swistock, a water resources extension associate with Penn State Cooperative Extension, 30 to 40 percent of this water flows back to the surface immediately after the well is fractured, and much of of the rest returns gradually along with the natural gas.

At a recent natural gas summit in Wysox, Swistock stated that while many elements of the hydraulic fracturing process have been mastered in western states such as Colorado and Wyoming, the treatment of flowback water is not one of them.

Pennsylvania's climate and geography, Swistock said, give the state a "limited capacity" to treat the water with evaporation or underground injection methods that were used in western states.

Swistock stated that before treatment, flowback water contains concentrations of materials such as barium, lead, and arsenic that, "compared to drinking water standards, are quite high."

A public hearing on the proposed wastewater treatment facility will be held on Nov. 18 at 7 p.m. in the township municipal building on Herrick Avenue.


Steve Reilly may be contacted at

Copyright © 2009 - The Morning Times

No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG -
Version: 8.5.422 / Virus Database: 270.14.20/2441 - Release Date: 10/16/09 18:39:00


Visit the Ithaca Unitarian Social Justice Council,
  to community event calendar with iCal, Lightning or Sunbird


Visit Tompkins County Against War & Occupation,

Weblog for Tompkins County War Resisters:

Subscribe  to community event calendar with iCal, Lightning or Sunbird.

Bill Huston          
Binghamton NY             Phone: 607-321-7846

Binghamton-area discussion; spirituality topics:
Watch for Open-To-Everyone TV!        

No comments: